Topological data analysis reveals genotype-phenotype relationships in primary ciliary dyskinesia

Amelia Shoemark, Bruna Rubbo, Marie Legendre, Mahmoud R Fassad, Eric G Haarman, Sunayna Best, Irma C M Bon, Joost Brandsma, Pierre-Regis Burgel, Gunnar Carlsson, Siobhan B Carr, Mary Carroll, Matt Edwards, Estelle Escudier, Isabelle Honoré, David Hunt, Gregory Jouvion, Michel R Loebinger, Bernard Maitre, Deborah Morris-RosendahlJean-Francois Papon, Camille M Parsons, Mitali P Patel, N Simon Thomas, Guillaume Thouvenin, Woolf T Walker, Robert Wilson, Claire Hogg, Hannah M Mitchison, Jane S Lucas

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

35 Citations (Scopus)


BACKGROUND: Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is a heterogeneous inherited disorder caused by mutations in approximately 50 cilia-related genes. PCD genotype-phenotype relationships have mostly arisen from small case series because existing statistical approaches to investigating relationships have been unsuitable for rare diseases.

METHODS: We applied a topological data analysis (TDA) approach to investigate genotype-phenotype relationships in PCD. Data from separate training and validation cohorts included 396 genetically defined individuals carrying pathogenic variants in PCD genes. To develop the TDA models, 12 clinical and diagnostic variables were included. TDA-driven hypotheses were subsequently tested using traditional statistics.

RESULTS: Disease severity at diagnosis, measured by forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1) z-score, was significantly worse in individuals with CCDC39 mutations (compared to other gene mutations) and better in those with DNAH11 mutations; the latter also reported less neonatal respiratory distress. Patients without neonatal respiratory distress had better preserved FEV1 at diagnosis. Individuals with DNAH5 mutations were phenotypically diverse. Cilia ultrastructure and beat pattern defects correlated closely to specific causative gene groups, confirming these tests can be used to support a genetic diagnosis.

CONCLUSIONS: This large scale, multi-national study presents PCD as a syndrome with overlapping symptoms and variations in phenotype according to genotype. TDA modelling confirmed genotype-phenotype relationships reported by smaller studies (e.g. FEV1 worse with CCDC39 mutation) and identified new relationships, including FEV1 preservation with DNAH11 mutations and diversity of severity with DNAH5 mutations.

Original languageEnglish
Article number2002359
JournalThe European respiratory journal
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2021

Cite this